Showing posts with label property taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label property taxes. Show all posts

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Is it still called property tax if it is tied to income?

As we go through the month of May, we'll see several prominent bills discussed at the state capitol. One such bill is the effort to change the way property taxes are paid. http://www.twincities.com/ci_9165066

The bill, authored by Ann Lenczewski, a DFLer from Bloomington, would shift property tax relief to those earning under $200,000 and whose property taxes account for more than 2% of their income. Who pays for it? Those whose property taxes are less than 2% of their income, and those whose households earn more than $200,000.

I don't like this bill on two levels: First, property taxes, along with sales taxes, are one of the last taxes tied to a discretionary purchase. You buy a $500,000 house, you probably will pay a few thousand dollars a year in property taxes. Likewise, if you are frugal and buy a $150,000 condo, you will have a lower tax bill. Your choice.

This bill would create a disincentive to live below your means and save money. If you earn a healthy income but choose to live in a modest home, you would see your property taxes increase to help cover the taxes of the person who was not as frugal on the housing front. It essentially eliminates anyting resembling a property tax and adds to an already considerable income tax here in Minnesota.

The second reason I don't like this bill is because it includes a cap on the amount of increase for local taxes as a component of the property tax. Under the bill, local taxes could only increase by 3% or the rate of inflation. In fairness to Lenczewski, this was an addition suggested by Governor Pawlenty. As I've written before, I don't like the state telling the cities what to do. If Shorewood decides to build a state-of-the-art community center that will require property taxes to increase by 6% a year, they should be able to. (for the record, I would disagree with this type of spending, but I think the council should be the ones to veto the idea, not a state-set cap). I'm not a tax-and-spend liberal, but I also believe in local control of fiscal matters.

I don't like this bill. We already have a plenty progressive tax code in Minnesota, and the property taxes you pay are one of the last taxes determined by something other than how much you earn. I'd like to see property taxes continue to be tied to property values and local levies, not earnings.

Sunday, December 30, 2007

School Funding Challenges - How Will The Housing Market Complicate Matters?

The Lake Minnetonka area has been very active with school funding topics lately. Minnetonka and Westonka both passed levy referendums in November, and the Hopkins school district recently exited statutory operating debt status just as Westonka announced that they had entered it. Statutory operating debt, in simple terms, occurs when the general operating fund balance falls below a certain threshold.

A question I haven't heard explored much recently is what impact, if any, the deteriorating housing market has on school funding going forward. Roughly 67% of school funds come from the State, while 18% comes from local property taxes. The remainder comes from school fee revenues and federal funds.

The 67% of State revenue is paid on a per-student basis, so it is fixed from the local school district's standpoint. There may be a budget crunch at the state level as they attempt to fulfill this obligation, but the localities can count on the money assuming they have accurately forecasted enrollment trends.

The levies that are paid from local property taxes come directly from a portion everyone's yearly tax bill. On your property tax statement, you can see what portion of your payment goes toward school funding.

The question isn't what the funding picture looks like in 2008 -- I think it is pretty well established. The concern is what assumptions have been made about property tax appreciation going forward? Are districts operating under an assumption that property taxes will continue to increase at a high clip, only to have actual revenue falls short of estimates? I understand there is still some room for tax valuations to grow based on actual market value and limited taxable market value, but there is less room to grow than there may have been in 5-year estimates done in 2006 or early 2007.

Does Minnetonka 2010 school district funding, for example, assume conservative or flat property tax revenue increases, or are the estimates based on the abnormally high rate of increase experienced in the 1st half of this decade?

With all of the financial specialists and auditors reviewing school finances, I'm sure this question has been actively explored. If anyone has insight into this, I'd appreciate the dialogue.