Showing posts with label referendum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label referendum. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

A Resounding "Yes": The Minnetonka School District Referenda

Two SD 276 levies passed with wide margins yesterday: A general operating levy (65%) and a technology levy (64%). A quick scan of the Star Tribune's election results shows that of the 65 metro-area school referendum questions on the ballot, only one school levy question (Edina - 72%) passed with more support than the two in Minnetonka.

There could be several theories on why this occured. It may be that the tax neutrality of the deal made it easy to vote for. Or perhaps the "Yes for Excellence" campaign was incredibly effective.

In scanning the election results, a correlation emerges: The two districts who supported their referenda by the largest margins, Edina and Minnetonka, happen to also be two of the top ten academic districts in the state. I'm not arguing a causal relationship -- I don't understand enough about the innards of school operations to do so. I just find it an interesting correlation.

The chicken-or-the-egg question comes in to play: Are these two districts really as good as they are because voters support spending tax dollars on them, or do voters feel better about their "yes" vote to a levy because of the pride of already having a great school district? Or maybe the same effective management of the district which persuaded us that these levies were truly necessary does a great job in other aspects of district management as well. The message of "this well-run district only asks for money when it truly needs to -- and this year it truly needs to" resounded with many, I believe.

Now that the levies passed, it will be important for the community to stay engaged with district. The district should continue to show us that funds are used wisely, innovation doesn't end, new ways to stretch an education dollar so it can impact more kids sought out and found. If they do, the next time they come with a similar referendum, whether it is 3 years or 10 years down the road, it will be another no-brainer for the community.

Minnetonka School District Election Results

All election results can be found here, based upon your zip code:
http://mpls.startribune.com/news/politics/elections/myvote/pf.php

In case you don't want to wait, the operating and technology levies passed by 65% and 64%, respectively. The four candidates elected to the school board were Lisa Wagner, Calvin Litsey, Paul Luehr, and Karen Walcowski.

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Where to Vote on Tuesday, Nov 6

To find your voting location for Tuesday's School District polling, go to the Secretary of State's website and type in your zip code and street. Voting locations are based on where you live.

http://pollfinder.sos.state.mn.us/

This mailer from SD276 also summarizes where you should vote based upon your home location:

http://www.minnetonka.k12.mn.us/referendum/mailer/P08.pdf

Reasoned Referendum Argument

Occasionally I like to post one of the submitted "comments" as an actual blog entry, especially if it presents information in a way that is more succinct and cogent than I've been able to. Attached is a comment from Peg Keenan in response to one of the comment posts from a recent thread:


Response to the Admiral:I can’t speak to what is going on in Westonka, where you live; however, I know in the Minnetonka School District the need for the referendum is real. With only a 1% increase in general education funding for 2008-2009, Minnetonka is facing a $3.4 million deficit. Minnetonka School District wisely used the 4% increase appropriated in 2005 to stretch all the way through 2007-2008 without budget cuts. They have had the authority to go to referendum since 2003 and have held off until 2007. The District is very well managed and only has approached voters when it became absolutely necessary. I also applaud the School Board for their plan to neutralize the tax impact of the operating referendum by decreasing the levy for long term maintenance. Residents should check out the online tax calculator at: http://www.ehlers-inc.info/taxInformation/Minnetonka/Our referendum investment in 2002 has provided great returns on our investment and student achievement has increased by almost every measure. I encourage everyone to read the Minnetonka School District Annual Report to see the incredible achievement. It is online at www.minnetonka.k12.mn.us/annualreport.pdf

Peg Keenan

Chair, Committee for Quality Academics

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Star Trib Comments on School Funding

The Strib devoted much of their Sunday Opinion page to school referenda and funding topics. While I'm guessing that anyone who reads this blog also reads our local papers, I thought I'd link to the columns just in case. They are interesting and provide additional context to an election year when about 1/3 of Minnesota districts are asking their residents for money.

The editorial was thought provoking for me. While I stand by my belief that funding at a local level is generally more efficient and accountable than pooling state or federal monies together and redistributing from afar, the Strib made a good point that funding by referendum is not very predictable or stable for the districts.

http://www.startribune.com/editorials/story/1510997.html
http://www.startribune.com/editorials/story/1510996.html

Saturday, October 20, 2007

Flaws in School Funding: A by-product of referendum research

Like most residents in School District 276, I've received much literature about the upcoming education referenda. I've read the literature, researched the SD 276 website, and listened to the board candidates answer the referenda-related questions at the candidate forums. I've come to this conclusion: It is very hard to make an argument for a "no" vote.

From a school funding standpoint, there is no doubt that the caliber of SD 276's education would suffer without sustained funding. These referenda don't create a cash infusion to the district -- they simply make the district whole after having state funding reduced to a trickle. While I appreciate the tax neutrality of the deal, I could live without that aspect. All debts must be repaid sooner or later, and I hope we aren't simply deferring more debt to later payment dates (something I have had a hard time finding succinct info on). If I need to pay more local taxes today to offset the state shortfall, I will.

In researching the referenda, I've learned something that I'm embarrased to say I didn't know before: The state has a cap on how much the district can levy, and we are at that cap (assuming all of the referenda pass). To me, this is the real issue rearing its ugly head in this funding equation. As someone who believes in local control of tax dollars, I am bothered that a centralized state government has set a limit on how much a locality can tax its people for a local service, especially when it would be decided by referendum.

I generally have a high degree of confidence that there is transparency and accountability tied to my local tax dollars: Police, schools, city government, etc. I have slightly less, but still considerable, comfort when it comes to county taxes. I'm really mixed on state taxes -- I see state taxes going to good causes and I like that they benefit those in my broad community, but don't always feel like they are used effectively. When it comes to federal taxes, all bets are off. Federal income taxes are the largest single expense that my family has, and I honestly can't tell you what it is being spent on or if it is being spent wisely. My whole point is that I would much rather pay local taxes than state, and state taxes than federal.

I was disappointed when I learned that not only does the state redistribute the educational tax dollar in a way that underfunds the western suburbs (as Rep. John Berns astutely pointed out in an Oct. 3 Commentary to the Star Tribune), and not only has the state been not keeping up with inflation in its recent funding of education in districts, but they completely tie our hands by limiting how much we can pay locally for the school systems we desire for our children.

In learning this, I feel like our founding fathers' vision of federalism has even failed on the most local level. I'm all for helping some of the poorer districts in the state provide their kids a better education with my tax dollar -- every child deserves a good education regardless of which neighborhood they happen to reside in. But if we as a district (and that really is who a school district is -- not the Superintendent, not the Board, but the community who funds it) want to provide our kids with educational opportunities that are above and beyond, and are fully willing to pay for it ourselves, why can't we?

Minnetonka school district not alone in asking for money

According to an MPR report this week, 1/3 of all Minnesota school districts are asking for money via referendum, with 60% of them request the renewal of an existing levy. The article can be found here:

http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2007/10/16/schoolmoney/

More to come with my thoughts on the topic of so many districts going to the public for more money, but for now I wanted to post the link.

Sunday, October 7, 2007

SD 276 Referendum Information

If you live in the Minnetonka school district, you are likely aware that residents will be voting on an education referendum in the November 6 election. I won't attempt to explain the nuts and bolt of the referendum, as other sites can do it more effectively. Both of these sites (one being SD 276's) are very much advocating a "Yes" vote to the referendum. I've tried to also find information from the "No" side in the spirit of balancing things out, but have not had any success.

http://www.minnetonka.k12.mn.us/referendum/QA.htm
http://www.yesforexcellence.com/